Copyright thinking...
Sep. 3rd, 2009 01:49 pmOK, so there are people who write craft books, and include patterns they're created. And they, quite naturally, often have little copyright notices saying that you can't use the patterns in a commercial manner - you can't sell stuff you've made from them, for instance. Which is all Right and Proper and I have no problem with.
...And then you come to something like the small pouch o'eyeballs I made for the Yuuko box where the pattern consists of an equilateral triangle 9" along each side. That's ... awfully basic. And the author and publisher are probably using "patterns" as a substitute for "don't sell anything resembling this thing because I thought it up and it's mine," but I just can't be sure in cases like that - what about an 8" or 10" triangle? Technically not using the pattern, but in spirit, yes. Harrumph.
(This is currently theoretical, and came up because I just ILLed a copy of Wagashi: handcrafted Fashion Art From Japan. Haven't looked through it yet, but I'm pondering where the line is between the pattern of a thing and the shape and thing-ness of a thing.)
...And then you come to something like the small pouch o'eyeballs I made for the Yuuko box where the pattern consists of an equilateral triangle 9" along each side. That's ... awfully basic. And the author and publisher are probably using "patterns" as a substitute for "don't sell anything resembling this thing because I thought it up and it's mine," but I just can't be sure in cases like that - what about an 8" or 10" triangle? Technically not using the pattern, but in spirit, yes. Harrumph.
(This is currently theoretical, and came up because I just ILLed a copy of Wagashi: handcrafted Fashion Art From Japan. Haven't looked through it yet, but I'm pondering where the line is between the pattern of a thing and the shape and thing-ness of a thing.)