![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
Entry tags:
Tale of Genji, 1-3
![[livejournal.com profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/external/lj-userinfo.gif){kind=small}
rachelmanija and kate_nepveu are reading The Tale of Genji by Murasaki Shikibu and I am a sheep baa.Well, ok, I've taken a stab or two at reading it before and got lost in who was who and what was what, so it rather helps to read someone else's commentary and the read it myself. For the two or three of you who may not know it, the Tale of Genji is the world's first novel, written by a woman at the Heian court approximately 800 years ago. Genji, the eponymous hero, is also possibly the world's first Mary Sue.
The best part about it all is seeing how many shoujo tropes have been in existence for the better part of a millennium at least.
I'm reading the Royall Tyler translation, which seems to have a decent amount of footnotes in it.
rachelmanija's reading a different version, and kate_nepveu's reading the Seidensticker translation.** marks typical shoujo tropes I picked out.
Chapter 1: The Paulownia Pavilion.
The Emperor loves Genji's mother, who is not of high enough rank to be a consort and is one of the lower-ranking concubines, to distraction, and therefore the
Interesting tidbit: "Genji" isn't really a name, it's a title signifying that he's been given a last name. In the Heian court, it seems that people go pretty much by their titles and not by names, which makes it confusing for later readers, many of whom have tagged various personages in the story with nicknames over the past eight hundred years.
The emperor finds a young girl who resembles Genji's motehr and raises her and marries her. Genji's in love with her too.** Genji has Issues.
Chapter 2: The Broom Tree
Genji's 17 (16 the way Western people count the years), a captain of the guard, and he and his buds are hanging out and drinking and bitching about women.
kate_nepveu's take on it is:What I got out of it: all failures of romantic or sexual relationships are the fault of the woman for failing to balance, to the man's taste, (a) assertiveness against rotten treatment by the man and (b) forgiveness for rotten treatment by the man. At least, according to the windy conversations of the men in the first part of the chapter.
My take on it is that it sounds like all the guys I knew in college who'd get together, drink beer, and bitch about chicks. Not much has changed in 800 years. At any rate, they tell a lot of stories and admire Genji for being Speshul and good-looking.**
Later on, Genji's forced to take refuge at a governor's house overnight - much to the governor's surprise and dismay - to avoid breaking a travel taboo, and starts crushing on the governor's stepmother, a young woman who is staying with the governor while her husband and the governor's father, the Iyo Deputy, is away deputying. She's not as taken with Genji as Genji thinks she ought to be, resisting even when he steals her away for a bit of fun.** Genji takes this as a challenge and employs her younger brother as a page and uses him as a go-between. The lady still resists, and at the end of the chapter Genji's more horny than ever and sleeps with her brother.**
This translation is slightly coy as to what exactly went on between Genji and the boy:
"Very well, then you, at least, shall not leave me." Genji had the boy lie down with him. The boy so appreciated his master's youth and gentleness that they say Genji found him much nicer than his cruel sister.
I call it "coy" if, when I was a teenager, I'd have completely missed the meaning of the passage.
Chapter 3: The Cicada Shell
A short chapter. Genji gets the boy to sneak him into his sister's presence as she's playing Go with another woman. The other woman isn't very attractive, although her demeanor and behavior is graceful. (ETA: Misreading there. See comments.) The boy intends to sneak Genji into his sister's room that night, but she guesses what he's up to and sneaks off. Genji manages to crawl into bed with the
When he's done, he and the boy sneak off, Genji filching an item of clothing that the sister dropped. He continues to moon about her and sends her poetry, which she resists. Much to the other woman's disappointment, she receives no poetry (Genji, you cad!). At the very end of the chapter, we learn that Genji's crush is secretly sad that she has to resist him.**
----------------
I found this bit of the introduction, by Tyler, amusing. It's in a section talking about the courtly language, which deals a lot in poetic metaphor and circumlocution instead of directness:
Some readers have wondered whether the men and women in the tale ever actually do anything, since they seem to spend their nights merely chatting; but katarau, which ostensibly means that, actually refers to other intimacies as well. ... A man who "sees" or "is seeing" a woman (a standard expression) is at least to some extent sharing his life with her, and Genji's having "seen" Utsusemi in a pitch-dark room (chapter 2) means bluntly that he has possessed her.Does anyone else catch the irony in using a word that in our modern language functions exactly like "seen" in Heian Japanese? To someone unfamiliar with "possess" as a euphemism for "have sex with," the meaning must be equally opaque.
no subject
i almost want to be a sheep too; it would be great to read it while people who write smart commentary are slightly ahead. :)
no subject
no subject
except that i am shielded by not liking to read books online! ha!
no subject
You can also go to a library or a bookstore. XD
*enables*
no subject
no subject
no subject
Haha! It's so true. I've never read the novel itself, but I have read a manga version of it, and I remember thinking, "Does Hikaru have any faults? And is there anyone who won't sleep with him?" I also came to the conclusion that it was the world's first soap-opera.
no subject
no subject
Yay, more people reading! What fun we shall have, snarking along.
no subject
with a great personalitybetter-mannered than Genji's crush, and more worthwhile knowing than the crush.Tyler seems to be going out of his way to underscore how shallow Genji is.
no subject
I *was* pleased that the author called Genji fickle and with a "less than pure" heart, though.
no subject
Seidensticker:
The eyelids seemed a trifle swollen, the lines of the nose were somewhat erratic, and there was a weariness, a want of luster, about the face. It was, one had to admit, a little on the plain side. Yet she clearly paid attention to her appearance, and there were details likely to draw the eye to a subtler sensibility than was evident in her lively companion.
Taylor:
With her perhaps somewhat puffy eyes and a nose vague enough in form to age her, she had no looks. Not to put too fine a point on it, she tended more toward the plain, but her exquisite manners made up for it, and she obviously had more to her than her prettier partner.
Yeah, Taylor's working the really-shallow-Genji angle here.
no subject
no subject
no subject
no subject
no subject
no subject
or maybe Murasaki just forgot to review her previous writingno subject